There is a small update on the hearing for resource consent to extract sand off Pakiri Beach.

The hearing began on the 1st of March 2021. The reconvening of the hearing on Monday 31 May was postponed after Kaipara Limited said that they would require additional time to provide their right of reply and were to provide a memo outlining the timeframe for their response. 

Kaipara Limited submitted a memo asking for clarification on points around the bathymetric survey and the associated expert discussions.

The commissioners have issued a direction in response outlining the division of responsibilities between the expert group (with qualifications and experience in relation to coastal processes) and Mr. Cox (the expert in hydrographic survey).

Kaipara submits it is entirely appropriate for the group to discuss area to be surveyed and the form in which the survey data is to be provided to the group. Kaipara respectfully submits it is improper for the group to dictate the survey methodology itself however, as that is a matter in which the only expert in hydrographic survey involved in this application is Mr. Cox. 

Mr. Cox shall provide to the expert group a copy of his proposed methodology of the bathymetric survey, including details of the survey data output. The expert group shall consider the proposed methodology and confirm that, from their perspective, the methodology will result in data that is reliable and fit for purpose.

Alternatively, the expert group will advise Mr. Cox of any concerns that they have with the proposed methodology before he finalises the methodology he will employ in the survey.

Consistent with previous directions, all participants and parties are reminded to act as promptly as is reasonable.